|#||Title||Image||Premiere||Finale||Status on IMDB/TV.com|
|10||Paddy the Pelican||September 11, 1950||October 13, 1950||1.5/10|
|9||Nutshack||April 25, 2007||May 31. 2011||1.9/10 (2.5/10)|
|8||Breadwinners||February 17, 2014||September 12, 2016||2.8/10|
|7||Mr. Pickles||September 21, 2014||N/A||7.4/10 (4.6/10)|
|6||Mega Babies||January 5, 1999||April 30, 2001||3.4/10 (4.4/10)|
|5||The Brothers Grunt||August 15, 1994||April 9, 1995||3.5/10 (5.7/10)|
|4||King Star King||June 15, 2014||December 6, 2014||5.9/10 (4/10)|
|3||Drawn Together: The Movie||April 20, 2010||6.3/10 (3.2/10)|
|2||Brian's a Bad Father & American Fung (Family Guy & American Dad!)|| Brian's a Bad Father: |
January 26, 2014
May 25, 2015
|Brian's a Bad Father: |
|1||Ren Seeks Help (Ren & Stimpy "Adult Party Cartoon")||July 3, 2003||3.3/10|
|Title||Image||Release Date||Status on Rotten Tomatoes/IMDB||Why It's Not on the List|
|Foodfight!||May 7, 2013||10% (1.7/10)||"It's lazy, it's got bad messages, it's phoned in, and is kind of annoying. But Nostalgia Critic already covered this one way better than I ever could, so I decided to leave it off the list."|
|Felix the Cat: The Movie||August 23, 1991||34% (5/10)||"This is among the cheapest animation I've ever seen. All I see is the third world animators when I see this stock crap. It's got annoying voices and abysmal animation. But again, Doug covered it way better, so I gave it a pass."|
- This is one of his most memorable videos, as each of his choices are involved in a lot of his later projects.
- This is the first time he uses Honorable Mentions.
- He will use the Worst Cartoons of All Time warning for the #1 choices for Worst Cartoon Characters, Worst Animated Sequels, and Worst Cancelled Cartoons.
- In Worst Cartoon Network Shows, he says Johnny Test almost made it to this list. It is unknown why it was left out in the end and not given a mention, but it was possibly because it has one decent episode.
- He says he left Foodfight! off the list since the "Nostalgia Critic" already reviewed it way better, but later calls it his #1 worst animated movie 5 months later on April 24, 2016.
- As of Worst Forgotten Cartoons, Slim Shady Show has replaced King Star King as the #4 Worst Cartoon of All Time.
- Releases his Worst Cartoons of All Time commentary on the video's 2nd anniversary (November 21, 2017).
- Ren Seeks Help (Ren & Stimpy "Adult Party Cartoon") remains the worst cartoon episode he has ever seen.